Member Hub
Member Hub
Study Hub ›
Bank of England

What are 'active' and 'passive' approaches to policy making?

Macroeconomic policy makers have clear goals know as macroeconomic policy objectives.

The main four (core) macro-economic policy objectives are:

  • Stable prices
  • Full employment
  • Stable and sustainable economic growth
  • A balance of payments

In addition to these core objectives, policy makers can set targets to control pollution and other negative externalities, and to achieve greater equity through reduction in inequality and poverty.

In recent years, the control and management of public finances is seen as an increasingly important objective, especially following the financial crash of 2008 to 2010, and the Covid-19 pandemic.

In this article, we will explore whether policy making should be active or passive. As a student of economics, understanding these debates will give you insights into the dynamic world of macroeconomics.

Policy making: Active or Passive?

There are two main schools of thought on policy making: the Keynesian economists and the Monetarists.

Keynesian economists argue that the economy is inherently unstable and advocate for active policy making using both monetary and fiscal tools to stabilise the economy. This approach is known as policy activism or fine tuning.

On the other hand, Monetarists believe that the economy is inherently stable, and fluctuations occur due to fine- tuning efforts. They propose a more passive approach to policy making.

How much do macroeconomists actually know?

Who is right; the Keynesians advocating fine-tuning of the economy, or the passive monetarists? Well, the answer depends on how much macroeconomics know. Macroeconomic policy makers in general do not have all the knowledge required for solving economic problems. They rely on macroeconometric models, all of which give different answers for how to solve a particular problem.

In a now famous paper, Blanchard (2006) looked at how 12 different models would simulate the impact of expansionary monetary policy. The graph below shows while all 12 models predicted that output would increase for some time in response to a monetary expansion, the range of answers regarding the size and the length of the output response was large.

Variations in economic forecasting

Source: Bank of England

We can therefore conclude that there is substantial uncertainty about the effect of any macroeconomic policy.

This is a win for the monetarist school of thought. They would say the economy is far too complex for us to fully understand. We should therefore stop tinkering with it, as we may well be doing more harm than good.

Lags in the implementation and effects of policies

Economists distinguish between two types of lags which are relevant to the implementation of policies.

These are:

Inside lags are the time between the shock (oil price spike for example) and the policy action. Since central bank independence in most OECD countries, monetary policy tends to have shorter inside lags compared to fiscal policy. This is because, most OECD countries are democracies and must get major changes to fiscal policy approved by their respective parliaments.

Outside lags are the time between the policy action and the impact on the economy. For example, it is widely believed that a change in base interest rates will have an outside lag of about 18 months before the full impact on the economy is realised.

Because of these lags, supporters of policy passivism (monetarists) argue that successful stabilisation policy is close to impossible. As a result of these lags policy decisions may be ill-timed.

For example, contractionary polices may be pursued when the economics is in fact over the boom phase of the economic cycle and into the cooling of phase. Equally expansionary polices may be pursued when the economy is heating up. All this can lead to the overshooting of macroeconomic policy targets.

The existence of inside and outside lags are convincing arguments against policy activism. However, they are far from the only lags policy makers must deal with.

Some more lags are:

  • Data lags
  • Recognition lags
  • Legislature lags
  • Impact lags

When taking all this into account you can quickly see why some economists say that managing an economy is like trying to drive a car by only looking in the rearview mirror. In other words, it is almost impossible to know where you are and what you should be doing at any given time. The monetarist conclusion is therefore clear: do nothing.

Conclusion

Uncertainty about the effects of policy, and the lags associated with implementation of the policy, should give policymakers pause for thought and encourage them to take a more restrained approach.

CPI inflation projection based on market interest rate expectations: Source: Bank of England

A recent of example of uncertainty in action is the Bank of England projections which you can view for yourself on their website. As you can see from the image, we have chosen you can see the orange line widens to show uncertainty.

inflation forecasts

Source: Bank of England

From our perspective now, CPI inflation could be anywhere between –2.0 and 4.0 in 2026. This shows how difficult it is to make the correct policy decision at the correct time.

As you can see from the chart there is a strong chance that the current monetary policy decisions of the Bank of England may lead to overshooting the 2.0 target, and even moving into deflation territory. Only time will tell.