A Level economics exam papers include multiple choice, essay and data response questions. Here, we consider how to approach a common type of data response question - namely, questions worth 8-10 marks.
These questions often get overlooked by students because, naturally, they look ahead to the end of the paper and upcoming 25-mark essay-style question. As a result, the 'mid-range' data response questions often get rushed. As with most things in life, there is no ‘hack’ or universal template which will guarantee success in this kind of question. Follow the principles laid out here and you will give yourself a good chance of success.
While we focus in particular on the 10-mark question on the UK's most popular exam board for economics, Edexcel (with over 50% of students sitting this board), all boards have similar data response questions.
The first principle is that, if we apply the mark-a-minute rule, 10 minutes should be allocated to the 10-markers including reading, identifying bits of the extract to refer to, planning and writing. So, writing and drawing a diagram (or two) will take up no more than 7-8 minutes - which really isn't very long. So, 10-markers need to balance 'getting it right' with 'getting it done' within the time.
The second principle provides some good news - unless the examiners are really unhelpful, the focus of a 10-marker is very narrow. It commonly involves just two variables (possibly three) and how they are related.
For example, for questions such as '..assess the impact of floods in Pakistan on the price of cotton.. ', or '..assess the likely impact of an new sugar tax on the market for sugary drinks..' require you to apply one event to one outcome (floods and price; a tax change and sugary drinks). In the vast majority of cases, a diagram is required to derive your answer.
So, if you know your topics and economic variables, and can read and extract information quickly, you will be able to cope comfortably with these questions.
The mark-scheme for a 10-mark question is typically based on the 'levels' method - it is often the first question where this marking method comes into play. The 10 possible marks are allocated in the following way:
Based on the quality, clarity and relevance of your use of economic knowledge, your application, and how you have analysed using a logical, step-by-step chain of reasoning, you will be entered into the 'best fit' level for (KAA).
The 10-mark questions allow 6/10 for KAA marks, laid out in three 'scoring' levels. Level 1 is a low score of just 1-2 marks; Level 2 is a medium attainment level, which scores either 3 or 4 marks, and Level 3 is the highest level, which scores either 5 or 6 marks. No KAA marks at all would mean Level - 0.
Evaluation (E) for a 10-mark question has two scoring levels. Level 1 provides 1 or 2 marks and has some 'general' evaluation points, while Level 2 is reserved for answers with very focused and relevant evaluation points, and provides 3 or 4 marks. Here, the difference between 3 or 4 marks often revolves around whether there is some critical assessment of the evidence, the assumptions, the data or theory.
10-mark questions typically use ‘assess’ as the 'command word' - at least for the Edexcel board. As we have said, these questions often expect you to write about the effects of an event or policy on an economic 'actor'. When you are asked to demonstrate the effects of something you must first think about how each economic actor is impacted.
There are three economic actors, or agents:
To help make an assessment we really need to know what motivates each of these economic actors, and what their expectations are. In other words, what are they hoping to gain from any economic interaction. This is summarised below:
Once you have identified how the economic actors might be impacted in terms of achieving their individual aims and objectives, and you have ordered them in terms of their significance, it is time to evaluate.
Evaluation requires you to ask questions of your analysis, any assumptions you have made, and the validity of the data given to you in the question. Here is a useful approach:
You can use the MATES framework to come up with evaluation points:
See more on evaluation techniques
With reference to the extract, assess the likely impact of the Help to Buy scheme on the market for rented properties. (10) [Courtesy Pearson-Edexcel]
The Help to Buy scheme is likely to increase the demand for home ownership, because it provides a financial incentive for first time buyers to 'get on the property ladder'. This is shown as a rightward shift from D to D1 in the diagram below. As a result, the price of privately owned property will increase, from P to P1.
The initial effect of this increase in demand for properties to own is that the demand for rented properties in the UK is likely to fall. This is because a purchased and privately owned house and a rented property are substitute goods - both providing a home for residents. This means that they have a positive cross elasticity of demand (XED). How close they are as substitutes will determine the magnitude of the cross relationship. It is likely that they are not perfect substitutes - partly because there are considerable differences in the consumer profile of home owners and renters. For example, renters will tend to be younger, with no or fewer dependents, and more geographically mobile. Also, purchasers of properties may consider the investment potential of the property, which adds another dimension to the demand for property to own. This is absent in terms of the demand for rented property.
The initial effect on the rented market it so see a reduction in demand as buying a house has become marginally more attractive and renting marginally less attractive. The demand curve will shift to the left from D to D1 in diagram below.
Falling demand for rented property creates a positive effect for renters, who will gain from the lower rents, and experience an increase in consumer surplus (the gained area is P1,a,b,P). Lower rents may also mean renters can save more - perhaps to save for a deposit the purchase a property in the future, or spend more on other goods or services. Conversely, falling rents will have a negative impact on landlords, who will experience a fall in their revenue and producer surplus.
However, in the longer run, the increase in demand for privately owned property will raise the price of houses. If this is sustained, perhaps fuelled by individuals seeing private property as an attractive investment, given the increase in price, there may be a subsequent increase in demand for rented property for those that are now 'priced out' of the market. This shows how interconnected these markets are.
The impact on the rental sector will depend on the scale of the increase in demand for houses for purchase as a result of Help to Buy. This will depend on how generous the scheme is. The more generous the scheme, the greater the incentive, the greater the demand and the bigger the impact on house purchases, and, therefore, on the rental market. However, the extract implies that the scheme is quite modest, so it is likely that the impact will be relatively small.
Of course, the price elasticity of demand and supply in both markets is also a significant factor. Rigidities in the house building market may prevent potential buyers taking up the scheme. Notice periods may also limit the short run impact of any changes in the rental market - renters may have to give many months notice to vacate their property to take advantage of the Help to Buy scheme.
Finally, the Help to Buy scheme may be short lived and might be withdrawn by the government, with a much smaller impact on both the private housing and rented markets.