facebook instagram youtube x

Protectionist policies

Trade protection involves the attempt to control the flow of imports into a country, and exports out of a country. This can be achieved by erecting barriers to trade.

The most frequently used barrier to trade are tariffs (customs duties) on goods entering a country, limits on the quantity of goods (quotas) that are allowed in, and subsidising exports (export subsidies). Barriers tend to be classified as either tariff or non-tariff barriers.

Tariffs

Tariffs or customs duties are taxes on the import of goods or resources.

The first documented example of a tariff was found in the Syrian oasis city of Palmyra in A.D. I37 and formed part of a new tax system introduced by the Roman Emperor Hadrian. The Palmyran tariff was imposed on goods flowing into and out of Palmyra. Like most early tariffs, its purpose was to raise revenue, but over-time tariffs began to be used as a means of controlling trade and protecting domestic producers.


From the middle of the 19th Century European states and the USA began to formulate comprehensive trade policies which involved placing tariffs on a range of imports.

Over time tariffs became an important source of revenue and a key part of trade policy. By 2019, US tariff revenue reached around $75bn, some 5% of all revenue. However, tariffs are a form of protectionism and while they raise revenue and protect domestic industries, the 'net' effect is generally agreed to be negative.

Video on tariffs

A tariff is, therefore, a tax on imports which raises revenue and protects domestic industries from overseas competition. Economic theory suggests that tariffs are likely to result in a net welfare loss to society.

The tariff diagram

Assuming no trade between a country and the rest of the world, economic welfare is area 'k a P', consumer surplus, plus 'P a 0', producer surplus.

Opening up to free trade increases consumer surplus to 'k e P1' but reduces producer surplus to 'P1 f 0'.

When the tariff is added to imports consumer surplus falls to 'k c P3', but producer surplus rises to 'P3 g 0'. The welfare loss is 'g c e f'. However, when tariff revenue of g c m u' is added, the net welfare loss is 'g u f' + 'c e m'.

Given this, trade organisations such as the World Trade Organisation (WTO) have actively promoted free trade through multi-lateral negotiations.

However, while the WTO has sought to reduce trade barriers, countries have typically sought protection from free trade either by erecting their own barriers, or by joining trading blocs which bring down barriers between members, but still retain barriers to non-members.

Non-tariff barriers

Non-tariff barriers include:

  1. Quotas - physical limits on imports.
  2. Favouring domestic firms over international ones - especially when involving 'public procurement' and contract allocation.
  3. State aid to industries or sectors which are susceptible to cheap overseas imports.
  4. Preventing imports using various spurious health and safety arguments - such a quarantine and border controls.
  5. Sanctions against another country.
  6. Currency controls - which make it harder to import from global markets.
  7. Export subsidies - which may enable cheap products to be 'dumped' at below cost on other countries.

Causes and consequences of adopting protectionist policies

The following have been used as justifications for imposing barriers to trade. Barriers can be used to:

  1. Raise revenue through customs duties.
  2. Protect industries or sectors including infant industries (also called sunrise industries, such as industries resulting from recent technologies, innovations and inventions) and declining industries (also called sunset industries, such as those using old technology, or where the pattern of demand has turned against a particular product).
  3. Save jobs which may have been lost as a result of declining industries and competition from low-wage economies.
  4. Save foreign currency or keep a currency from depreciating. Every imported good means that currency flows out of a country. While this is not in itself a problem, for some less developed countries an outflow of currency reduces their ability to purchase needed goods, services and technology from industrialised countries. This can inhibit their growth and development.
  5. Protect a country for health or environmental reasons, including import controls on animal products, or products with a high carbon footprint.
  6. Help improve food and fuel security where countries might increasingly be dependent on imports.
  7. Retaliate against countries who have imposed barriers to trade on their exports.
  8. Prevent dumping of cheap goods from abroad, which may be sold at prices below their true cost of production.
  9. Promote a particular foreign policy, such as the 'America First' policy.

Consequences of protectionist policies

The consequences of protectionist policies relate to the motives for imposing barriers, and whether the goals have been achieved. Here, we summarise some of the major effects of protectionism:

  1. Loss of benefits from free trade, including:
  2. Less able to apply the principle of comparative advantage - countries need to be more self-sufficient.
  3. Less able to gain from economies of scale.
  4. Higher prices because of protectionist measures.
  5. Loss of economic welfare - see tariffs.
  6. Trade diversion as efficient producers are unable to gain access to protected markets.

Read more - The World Trade Organisation