facebook instagram youtube x

Barriers to entry

Barriers to entry are the constraints faced by potential entrants into a market which may deter entry, and therefore reduce competition in a market.

Structural barriers to entry

Structural barriers to entry (also called natural barriers) result from specific features of an existing market which deter entry but are not the result of the deliberate actions of existing (incumbent) firms to prevent entry.

Structural barriers include:

Economies of large-scale production

Significant economies of scale can deter new entrants into a market when the existing firms - the incumbents - have obtained the benefits of these economies of scale.

Economies of scale refer to the cost savings that come with operating at large scale. These benefits include purchasing inputs at low cost, and savings resulting from management and administration costs which may be spread across multiple business units or multiple locations. Being able to purchase raw materials at discount prices and gaining increased access to financial markets, and bearing greater risk are also benefits of operating at large scale.

An incumbent firm is likely to have exploited many of these economies of scale, placing them in a strong position. Conversely, potential new entrants may not be able to exploit these benefits in the short run, and hence are less likely to enter a market where economies of scale are significant.

Of course, against this it may be that larger firms can also suffer from diseconomies of scale which can enable smaller, more flexible and dynamic firms, to enter a market.

Ownership or control of a key scarce resource

Owning, or controlling, the scarce resources needed for production and supply in a particular industry can create a considerable barrier to entry.

For example, incumbent airlines may control access to a particular airport as a result of purchasing landing rights for that airport, which forces other (start-up) airlines to use less popular or less convenient airports. This may mean that the routes they offer are less profitable, preventing them from challenging the dominant airlines.

High set-up (capital) costs

Set-up costs refer to the initial capital costs associated with entering a market and typically include fixed costs such as equipment, premises and machinery. When these costs are large, entry is deterred, because they increase break-even output, and delay the possibility of making profits.

Many of these costs are also sunk costs, which are those costs that cannot be recovered when a firm leaves a market. Sunk costs include infrastructure costs, such as cables and networks, as well as marketing and advertising costs.

High research and development (R&D) costs

Expenditure on research and development (R & D), which may be very high in oligopolistic markets such as pharmaceuticals and chemicals, may deter possible entrants. New entrants are unlikely to be able to match the levels of expenditure of incumbent firms - leaving existing firms to dominate the market.

Advertising

Advertising expenditure, which is a sunk cost, can deter new entrants because it increases the level of cost required to enter a market and compete effectively with incumbent firms. The more that existing firms spend on advertising, the greater the deterrent to new entrants.

[It should be noted that where advertising expenditure and spending on R&D is undertaken in a direct attempt to deter entry it is classed as a behavioural rather than structural barrier. Of course, it may be impossible for regulators to determine the intent behind such expenditure.]

A strong brand

The strength of the brand of incumbent firms affects the price elasticity of demand (PED) of a potential entrant.  A strong brand creates loyalty to that brand and, to some extent, ‘locks in’ existing customers - hence reducing PED for the potential entrant.  This presents a challenge to potential entrants, who may have to spend more in the short run to build a brand capable of challenging existing firms.

Superior knowledge

An incumbent firm may, over time, have built up a superior level of knowledge of the market, its customers, and its production costs.

The superior knowledge of an incumbent can give it considerable competitive advantage over a potential entrant and, as a result, deter new entrants. This will be particularly significant in industries where technical knowledge and expertise are important in the design and delivery of products, such as with consumer electronics, motor manufacture and social media platforms.

Legal barriers

Existing firms may be protected by legislation, including patents and copyrights.

These protect the holders of the patent or copyright for a period of time.

Network effects

Network effects can deter new firms from entering a market or industry where they exist. A positive network effect for a business arises when increasing numbers use the good or service, resulting in an increase in the utility derived by consumers. As more consumers use a product, each user gains from the increasing spread of the product across increasing number of consumers or users.

The 'classic' example of network effects is the growth of the telephone (and, today, the smartphone and social media platforms). In the case of telephones, as more consumers use a telephone, each user gains and the value of having a phone (or smartphone) increases. This, in turn, encourages more users. As these users are attracted to the product of one supplier, other firms may find it difficult to get a foothold in the market. This is amplified as a result of the higher prices that existing firms can charge, and the increased profits available to incumbents. These profits can be used to make further developments to the product, encouraging more consumers, and, consequently, adding perceived value to consumers.

Existing firms can also take advantage of improving their services by using feedback from the growing numbers of consumers and users. It is not clear whether potential entrants are deterred when an existing firm develops its service and gains a network effect.

For example, while the network effect available to the social media platform, Facebook (now Meta) helped in hastening the demise of MySpace and Friends Reunited, other social media companies have been able to enter the market, build rival platforms, and gain their own network effects. This includes the social media players, WhatsApp, (bought by Facebook in 2014) Linked in (bought by Microsoft in 2016) and Snapchat (still independent, but was subject to a failed bid by Google in 2016).

Behavioural barriers

Behavioural (or artificial) barriers result from the deliberate actions of incumbent firms to make entry into a market difficult. These barriers include:

Limit pricing

Limit pricing exists when an incumbent firm deliberately sets a low price, so than possible entrants cannot make a profit if they try to match that price. A 'limit' price is the highest price which the incumbents assess they can charge without encouraging new entrants.

This is most effectively achieved by selling at a price just below the average total costs (ATC) of potential entrants. This signals to potential entrants that profits may be difficult to make, perhaps impossible to do so. While this is likely to result in the incumbent operating below profit maximisation (where MR = MC), and, in the short run, making a loss. However, if the limit pricing strategy provides a deterrent to entry, the incumbent firm can move nearer to profit maximisation in the long run.

Predatory acquisition

Predatory acquisition involves taking-over a potential rival by purchasing sufficient shares to gain a controlling interest, or by a complete buy-out.

As with other deliberate barriers, regulators, such as the UK's Competition and Markets Authority (CMA), may prevent this if it is likely to lead to a substantial lessening of competition.

Loyalty schemes

Loyalty schemes, such as those offered by supermarket and coffee chains, can help build a brand and increase customer loyalty. New entrants are deterred because highly loyal customers of existing firms are difficult to win.

Exclusive contracts, patents and licenses

Contracts, patents, and licenses make entry difficult as they protect existing firms who have won the contract, who own the license or who hold the patent. Exclusive agreements between specific suppliers and retailers will exclude other retailers from entering the market.

Switching costs

Switching costs are those costs incurred by a consumer when trying to switch suppliers. They can involve costs of purchasing or installing new equipment, loss of service during the switching process, and the effort involved in searching for a new supplier or learning a new system.

Switching costs are common when changing energy suppliers, banks, TV and telephone suppliers.

While these may also be structural in nature, it is common to refer to them as behavioural (strategic) barriers as they are exploited by suppliers. Research by the Commission on Banking found that, in the UK, people only change bank accounts once every 26 years - it was against this that, in September 2013, UK banks were forced to make the process of switching of bank accounts much easier.

Vertical integration

Vertical integration can ‘tie up’ the supply chain and make life difficult for potential entrants. For example, Netflix has been able to exert control much of the supply chain for film streaming services by the acquisition of several film production companies, and film studios, including the Roald Dahl Story Company in 2021, and Finnish film studio, Next Games in 2022. These are example of backwards vertical integration because Netflix is acquiring firms that produce content for its streaming service. This helped Netflix maintain its number one position with a 27% market share (in the US) ahead of Amazon Prime Video (at 21%), and Disney+ (at 14%). In the film streaming market, as with many other markets, vertical integration makes it much harder for new entrants to get a foothold in the market.

Backwards vertical integration ties up the supply chain, and forwards vertical integration helps control the outlets for goods and services. While this creates many benefits for the firms involved (such as benefitting from economies of scale), it limits the possibility of new entry and can reduce competition in the market and inhibit innovation.

Evaluation of barriers to entry

Barriers to entry clearly benefit those firms already in a market over those attempting to get into a market.

The benefits of entry barriers include:

  1. Protects existing market share.
  2. Enables long run super-normal profits.
  3. May encourages expenditure on R&D, leading to product innovation.
  4. At the macroeconomic level, barriers into a domestic market may act as a deterrent to overseas exporters (and reduce imports into a territory), and hence help improve the balance of payments. However, it could be argued that such barriers encourage the acquisition of local (incumbent) firms by international firms as a way of avoiding market barriers. This can encourage inward investment and the transfer of technology from one country to another.

Against this, there are several potential disadvantages of barriers to entry, including:

  1. The benefits of competition, including lower prices, higher output, allocative and productive efficiency, and higher quality will be lost when new (dynamic) firms cannot enter a market.
  2. The market is likely to become (or remain) concentrated and less contestable.
  3. A lack of new entrants reduces dynamic efficiency as incumbents may have no incentive to innovate, or undertake minimal innovation (just enough to deter new entry.)
  4. Increased 'x' inefficiency as a lack of competition means that managers employed by incumbent firms do not need to keep costs under control.
  5. Incumbents may be able to gain from monopsony power, including paying below-equilibrium wages.
  6. Widespread barriers can result in a sub-optimal supply-side performance across the economy.