facebook instagram youtube x

Specialisation and trade

Specialisation occurs when factors of production - land, labour, capital and enterprise - perform a limited and specific role in the production process. This means that factors can be used efficiently as they play their part in the overall process.

The division of labour refers to the process of breaking up a complete job or process into smaller tasks so that each element only performs a limited role.

The division of labour and specialisation are closely interconnected concepts. Dividing up a job into smaller tasks enables the resources to be used in a specialised way and as a result become more productive.

This means that individuals, producers and whole countries will become more productive if they specialise.

Exchange

When economic processes are divided up, allowing economic agents to specialise, there is a need to exchange and trade. For example, if a farmer produces only one crop it is necessary to exchange any surplus produced in order to obtain crops and other goods and services that the farmer does not produce. The more efficient the farmer becomes in terms of producing their own crop, the more surplus will be produced, and the greater the quantity available to be traded.

Hence, specialisation, rather than self-sufficiency, creates the need for exchange, and provides a means by which resources can be used efficiently - as resources are scarce, getting more output from them is a rational strategy to improve the prosperity of individuals, producers and whole economies.

What is the alternative?

The alternative to specialisation is for factors to perform a less focused and more general role and undertake a range of tasks. For example, in terms of the use of capital, simple tools can be put to a variety of uses. A hammer can be used for many jobs, but a set of pliers is a more specialised tool, and has a limited number of uses. The more specialised the instrument or factor, the fewer the uses. In agricultural societies, individuals are commonly expected to be 'jacks of all trade' - clearing land, sewing seed, tending the land, gathering the crops, and turning the crops into food. However, in undertaking such a range of tasks they are 'masters of none'.

As Adam Smith, the founding father of economics, noted in the 18th Century, specialisation and the division of labour form the basis of the wealth of all nations. Smith also noted that exchange becomes essential if specialisation is to be successful. This means that countries would need to trade freely to gain the benefits of specialisation. As an example, he famously referred to winemaking in Scotland when he observed that:

‘..by means of glasses, hotbeds, and hotwalls, very good grapes can be raised in Scotland, and very good wine too can be made of them at about thirty times the expense for which at least equally good can be brought from foreign countries. Would it be a reasonable law to prohibit the importation of all foreign wines, merely to encourage the making of claret and burgundy in Scotland?’1

Today, all economists share Smith's view that specialisation increases output beyond that which could be achieved through self-sufficiency.

Benefits of the division of labour and specialisation

  1. Increases in the level of factor productivity with more output from a given quantity of inputs. The key to this is that specialisation allows the application of the principle of comparative advantage.
  2. Individuals will deepen their skills, and be able to earn a higher income from selling their labour.
  3. It is easier to apply technology when tasks are broken down into smaller elements.
  4. Producers will improve the quality and reliability of their products.
  5. Surpluses can be produced which enables countries to trade with other countries.

Costs of the division of labour and specialisation

  1. Labour productivity can fall if workers become bored with repetitive tasks.
  2. Workers may become dependent on other workers or on technology.
  3. Workers do not develop a full range of skills.
  4. Changes in demand for goods or services can lead to structural unemployment.

Limits on specialisation

If the benefits of specialisation are so clear, why is it not applied to all production? There are several reasons.

The size of the market might be small, and specialisation is simply not appropriate or feasible. For example, the market for piano tuners is so limited that piano tuners must be able to complete all aspects of the job. Although the task requires considerable skill, the market is too small to justify any division of labour, and piano tuners will tend be sole traders.

The skills required for some tasks may be so specific that few people are capable of acquiring these skills. Similarly, some skills are related to technology, and not all countries will have access to complex technology.

There may be a considerable time-lag between training and acquiring skills, and being able to trade successfully. In less developed countries the reward from working on the land - though small and perhaps unpredictable - will be available quickly, whereas the rewards from more specialist work will be delayed until after lengthy training.

The provision of education and training might be limited in some countries. Education and training are merit goods, and may be under-supplied, so that only countries with advanced educational systems will be able to supply the skills necessary for workers to fully specialise.

As mentioned, there is a risk of over-specialisation, which may put a limit on how much specialisation can occur.

Specialisation requires trade and exchange, but trade may be restricted as a result of barriers to trade, such as tariffs and quotas.

Money, its functions and characteristics

Money can be loosely defined as anything that is acceptable in the settlement of a debt. More specifically, money fulfills the following four key functions:

  1. Medium of exchange - without a medium of exchange, trade and commerce would rely on direct exchange of goods and services for other goods and services - called barter. Money evolved to solve the problems associated with barter, and so long as all parties in a transaction agree of what they will accept, any asset could be a medium of exchange - from precious metals, to printed paper money, to digital crypto currencies. However, the most efficient assets to fulfill the functions of money should be:

  2. Acceptable

    Divisible into smaller units

    Portable

    Storable


    This means some assets make 'better' money than others. Generally, precious metals can be divided up, they can be stored and they are acceptable. However, they are not very portable, and hence in the evolution of money and banking printed paper became the dominant form of money accepted globally. From printed currencies, to writing and accepting cheques, to digitisation and advancements in technology, paper money has slowly given way to direct and secure transfers between computers through the banking clearing system, and new platforms which can deal with transactions in cryptocurrencies. Whatever form money takes, its primary function remains the same - as a medium of exchange.


  3. Store of wealth (or value). The second key function of money is that it provides a method by which individuals, organisations and governments can store their wealth. They either store their wealth in a liquid form, including cash, or they can deposit it for safe keeping in a bank. However, while money is a store of wealth it is subject to depreciation caused by inflation (which erodes its value). The common solution is to store value in physical assets, such as property, land, and business assets. This leads us to money's third function - as a unit of account.

  4. Unit of account. The holders of assets know the worth of these assets because they attach a monetary value to them - holders of wealth can account for the value of their wealth in terms of the accepted currency of a country. Clearly, the function of 'unit of account' is much wider than just accounting for asset values. Goods and services are priced in terms of money, as are wages, profits and rents.

  5. A means of delaying (deferring) payment. With direct exchange of goods, payment is expected there are then - on the spot. When money is used as a medium of exchange it leads to the possibility of buying now and paying later - in other words, it allows for 'credit' purchases. This is especially important in that expensive assets or goods and services can be purchased out of future income, rather than current income. Very few individuals would be able to fund the purchase of real estate without the ability to acquire credit through a mortgage. The same is trues for automobile purchases.

Trade by barter

Without money as a medium of exchange societies would have to trade through barter. This means the direct exchange of one good or service for another one. However, an effective barter system is unlikely to develop are a result of inherent weaknesses in a barter system, including:

  1. How to value one good or service in terms of another one - are 4 apples worth 3 oranges, or 2?
  2. Values would be difficult given that goods and services vary in quality. A haircut from one trader is unlikely to be the same as one from another trader.
  3. Values will also be difficult to establish as many goods may be perishable. What is delivered may be very different from what was seen at the time of the trade.
  4. Services cannot easily be traded given this variability in value.
  5. Consider time will be wasted in haggling over value, which might be better spent in producing.
  6. There needs to be a double co-incidence of wants for a satisfactory trade - in other words, what one trader brings to market to sell must be desired by a buyer (a single co-incidence) but the buyer must also offer something that the seller wants in order to complete the trade (a second co-incidence of wants).
  7. Because of this, only basic goods and service will be produced as it would be too risky to specialise in a good with limited or niche appeal.

The conclusion is that the use of money as a medium of exchange solves the problems associated with barter, and as long as the form of money used is acceptable to all parties, then trade will occur and economic agents can specialise in the knowledge that their ability to specialise will be rewarded by payment in an acceptable medium which they can then use to purchase the goods and services they need.


Comparative advantage

How does comparative advantage related to specialisation?

Comparative advantage
Economic systems

What are the costs and benefits of mixed economies?

Mixed economy
The economic problem

What is the economic problem?

The economic problem


Sources and endnotes

1. Smith, A, The Wealth Of Nations, (1776) Book IV, Chapter II, p. 458, para. 15.